Recent framework agreement
between Iran and West (USA) is an important milestone and it could transform
the geopolitics of the Middle East. It opens up considerable diplomatic space
for India. While Iran had loomed large in India’s considerations on energy
security, Afghanistan and the engagement with Central Asia, the escalating conflict
between America and Iran severely constrained Delhi’s freedom of action beyond
India’s northwestern frontiers. As the USA ends its combat role in Afghanistan,
strategic cooperation with Iran has become absolutely critical for securing
India’s interests in Afghanistan and Central Asia.
There
is a general consensus that USA power in middle-east / Gulf is waning, the
trajectory of this expected demise is yet to be determined; will it be a sudden
fall or will it be a gradual one? Meanwhile, the International Energy Agency
(IEA) estimates that China and India - ("Chindia") - will witness the
highest rate of growth in their energy consumption between now and 2030. Hence,
one can predict with confidence that Chindia will go head to head with the USA
and its European allies, and perhaps with one another, within the context of
the evolving geopolitical contest over Middle Eastern oil and gas.
Strategically, the Straits of Hormuz
through which 80% of the oil pass : both India and China worry that a blockade
of these chokepoints would lead to supply disruption. For now, the US navy is
still dominating and ensuring the security of the routing, and according to
Geoffrey Kemp their replacement in a nearer future seems rather unlikely due to
the inferiority of Indian and Chinese navies. The Indian Ocean Region, through
which most of the oil passes, is considered by the Indians as their natural
zone of influence, and by the Chinese as a strategic zone that needs to be
controlled.
In
foreign policy imagination of USA, India is not frequently seen as having
direct interests in, or having larger strategic connections with the “greater
middle east,” but that assumption overlooks important historical, social and
economic linkages. Kerala’s Syrian Christians trace their origins to St. Thomas, who
arrived in Kerala in 52 CE. The first Muslims in India were in Kerala,
predating the eighth century arrival in Sindh by Muhammad bin Qasim, is the
result of maritime Indian Ocean trade with the Gulf during the seventh
century. The scholar Sanjay Subrahmanyam has argued that Gujarat was a
“linchpin” in commerce across the western Indian Ocean during the
early modern era. Connectivity by sea, across the Indian Ocean Basin, reveals a
history of deep trading linkages between India and the Gulf throughout early
modern and modern history.
Earlier, India
was not looking to fill any kind of vacuum left by withdrawing American presence;
it was willing to provide only “logistics” in areas such as
counter-terrorism, intelligence building, protection of sea-lanes and capacity
building. However, Delhi needs to take a fresh strategic look at the region, discarding
many of its outdated political assumptions and initiate a sustained political
engagement with all the major actors (Iran, Saudis, Israel and Turkey).
India’s
energy needs have led to extensive oil and gas relationships across the Middle
East, where the Gulf is the main source for India’s oil imports,
accounting for 82 percent of its overall needs. For its part, Delhi must gear up to deal with
a region that has not got high-level Indian political attention in recent
years. As it looks forward to new opportunities in Iran, Delhi must also reach
out to its Arab neighbors, some of whom are deeply concerned about the
consequences of a USA-Iran rapprochement. To secure its massive political and
economic stakes in the Middle East, India has to compete with combined spectrum
of China-Russia (and Pakistan). Also, it has to balance rivalry between
Shias-Sunnis blocs and Israel.
India has agreements with
Qatar (short of stationing troops), Saudis and Iran (secret) which would help
in case of any conflict or blockade. Recently, diplomatic exchanges between India
and the West Asian region led to a diplomatic traffic jam in New Delhi, with
Saudi Prince Salman bin Abdulaziz al Saud, Iranian Foreign Minister Dr. Javad
Zarif and Oman’s Foreign Minister Yousif bin Alawai bin Abdullah visiting
within hours of each other. The fact that the Saudi and Iranian delegations
were in New Delhi without causing any noise over each other’s presence shows
the importance that India now holds in the region’s economy, politics and
society. India has had close relations with Iran for centuries, and has
maintained the same through Tehran’s period of international sanctions over the
past few years. India's ties with Iran may
have been caused hiccups in its relations with Israel, but with India's
emergence as a growing economy, it can afford to do business with other nations
on its own terms as well.
Accordingly,
India's investment plan to set up the Chabahar port in Iran, India stands to
gain a lot as the port could provide it with an important transit point to
Afghanistan. It is also strategically located, just about 70 km from the
China-Pakistan jointly developed Gwadar port. All this suggests
that India seems to have got the balancing act right in furthering bilateral
relations with both Iran and Israel simultaneously. Both the countries hold a
lot of strategic importance for India, economically and geopolitically, and
with both nations willing to do business it is up to India to take these
relations even further.
India, China
and the USA are all pursuing a grand policy referred as "New Silk
Road" strategy, seeking to establish their dominance over the vast natural
resources of the Middle East and Central Asia. Given Iran's geography, Tehran
should naturally be the cornerstone of this strategy. India has been developing a defense
and military cooperation with Iran since 2001. This can actually be explained
by the geographical position of Iran at the Western border of Pakistan, and by
the strategic interest of India to have allies within the Muslim world which
could support it in case of war over Kashmir. According to specialists, there
was a secret agreement which would allow Indian troops to attack from Iran in
case of a war between India and Pakistan. If the Indo-Iranian partnership seems
on a better track than the Sino-Iranian one, the Chinese on the contrary are in
a better position in Saudi Arabia. Saudi Arabia has replaced Iran as China’s
major supplier in 2009, and is also India’s most important supplier. However,
politically the relations between India and Saudi Arabia have been quite tensed
due to the Saudi support to Pakistan, and financing of Islamic schools in India
at a time of increasing internal interreligious conflicts. In spite of these
tensions, Saudi Arabia is still considered by India as a possible counterweight
to Pakistan in the Islamic world.
Finally, at least for near future, the
United States remains the major player in the Middle East region, and that it
will for sure try to maintain its dominant position. In this context, Indian PM
Modi’s visit to Israel will have an important strategic repercussion in
middle-east Geopolitics.





No comments:
Post a Comment